|
A worry today is counterfeit rugs with
the Seirafian signature. See Fake
Serafian Signatures. Mohammad Seirafian mentioned to
me that it was a problem with the old signatures but that
they added a signature in English and Farsi. Mohammad
Seirafian said that he never saw one of these forged.
Still one should keep in mind that the older Seirafians
have the older signature. Provenance becomes important.
It is best to know where the rug has been.
Haj Agha Reza Seirafian's seven sons:
Mohammed Ali Seirafian
Mohammad Seirafian
The Late Mohammad
Sadegh Seirafian
Ahmad Seirafian
Ali Seirafian
The Late Hossien Seirafian
Mohammad Hassan
Seirafian
|
Provenance: The provenance
of a rug is becoming ever more important. The
difference between a very good quality Isfahan
carpet and a signed Seirafian carpet can be
considerable. So the authenticity of the
signature and thereby the rug is a factor in
valuation.
How
do I know that the rug to the left is a
Seirafian? (Signature above) I have the advantage
that I know it is because Mohammad Seirafian
personally showed it to me as an example of his
work and posed for a picture with it. How else
can we authenticate a Seirafian Rug:
Documentation.
A bill of sale, a shipping document, a letter
from Seirafian are all good.In this article we
have four rugs authenticated by the workshop of
Sadegh Seirafian. The documentation is by email
which is less desirable than a letter but it
certainly helps in authentication. If the
documentation is not from Seirafian themselves
then the dealer is important.For instance when it
comes to questions about Seirafian rugs I would
accept the opinion of Mr. Rahim Soltani of
Beverly Hills without question. Documentation
that you bought a rug from Mr. Soltani would be
very convincing. On the other hand a stack of
documentation from "Shifty-Dealer" on
eBay would mean virtually nothing.
Other factors come into play besides
paperwork. We may expect a signed Seirafian
workshop piece to be no less that 9 by 10 knots
to the centimeter. We can expect the workmanship
to be exceptional. I would not expect to see
retied broken warps. However with the variation
of the width of the cotton wefts I would not
expect the weave to have a rigid grid like
uniformity.
Isfahan Rug
A note about the signatures in this article
except for the montage of signature forgers all
rugs on this page are authentic to the very best
of my knowledge. They were authenticated by
Mohammed Seirafian, the workshop of Sadegh
Seirafian, or Mr. Rahim Soltani of Beverly Hills.
|
We have to be aware of fakes and
forgeries because people are making a business out of the
fraud. Here we have a montage of signature forgers taken
in Isfahan a few years ago.
Keep in mind that forgers are adding
the signatures to lesser quality rugs. The first place to
spot a fake is on the basis of weave, design and
sophistication.
|
Mohammad Seirafian
Plate 14 Top and Bottom Signatures I sharpened
up the contrast to enhance the signature.
Unfortunately it throws the color off.
|
|
This rug has been authenticated by
the workshop of the late Master Sadegh Seirafian.
|
|
This rug has been authenticated by
the workshop of the late Master Sadegh Seirafian.
|
|
This rug has been authenticated by
the workshop of the late Master Sadegh Seirafian.
|
Mohammed Ali
Seirafian's Signature
This rug has been authenticated by Mr. Rahim Soltani of
Beverly Hills.
What does the signature really mean?
In the very best rugs it is a guarantee that the rug
is of first quality. Above we see a rug that failed to
meet Seirafian standards and was cut. When one considers
the cost of production cutting a rug is a serious thing.
Seirafian feels that selling a substandard rug is even
more serious. An authentic signature is that guarantee.
Guide
to Seirafian of Isfahan
Oriental Rugs the O'Connell
Notes
Copyright Barry
O'Connell 2004 - 2007
Last revised: May 29, 2008.
|
Persian
Rugs/
Turkmen
Rugs/Turkmen
Rugs
Baluch
Rugs
Uzbek
Rugs
Books
Caucasian
Rugs
Caucasian
Rugs
Turkish
Rugs/Turkish
Rugs
People
Discussion
New
York Times Article
Greek
Rugs
The
Hazara
Islamic
Art
Kirghis
Rugs
The
Pazyryk Carpet
McMullan
on the Pazaryk
Moroccan
Carpets
Rugs
of Palestine
Rugs
and Textiles
Major Rug Sites
Notes
on the Shaykh Lutfallah Mosque
Time
and Links
Guide
to the Best Rug Societies
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Alabama
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Arizona
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of California
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Colorado
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Delaware
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Florida
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Georgia
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Hawaii
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Illinois
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Indiana
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Kansas
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Kentucky
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Maryland
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Massachusetts
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Missouri
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of New Hampshire
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of New Jersey
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of New Mexico
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of New York
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Oregon
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Pennsylvania
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Tennessee
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Texas
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Vermont
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Virginia
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Washington
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Washington DC
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Italy
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of Germany
Guide
to the Best Carpet Producers and Dealers of Turkey
Guide
to the Best Carpet Dealers of the United Kingdom
Naein
Rugs By Ehsan Afzalzadeh Naini Of Iran Rug Co.
Guide
to the Best Carpet Producers and Dealers of Iran
Guide
to the Best Auction Houses
Guide
to the Best Book Dealers
Guide
to the Best Carpet Cleaners and Restorers
Guide
to the Best Carpet Producers and Dealers of Central Asia
Guide
to the Best Rug & Carpet Appraisers
|